Earlier this evening, we were in the process of ending the giveaway early as entries had tapered off. While drawing our two winners, we tripped some sort of spam filter on Gleam and have been requested to provide proof that these account upgrades are legitimate -- essentially, they want to verify the validity of this giveaway. As a result, our giveaway with Gleam is currently suspended. I've already reached out to Gleam with the requested information and hope to hear from them soon but I'm not sure how soon I'll receive a response with Christmas just three days away.
Good news is, we've already drawn our two winners and managed to collect a bit of data from the submissions. Unfortunately, we don't have access to the text entry data for 'what one feature we should add' and 'Christmas memories'. It's rather disheartening to have this happen at such an inopportune time as we had planned to share some of the great stories and ideas we had received. What we do have is clear winners in software additions and the features listed in our Feature Plan that users are most excited about. We also found that our Christmas theme, while simple in design, was a resounding success. Check the bottom of this thread for more details on this data.
As for the giveaway, we will be reaching out to our two winners on Twitter in the next few minutes. Winners will need to DM us by 11:59pm EST today (12/22) with their forum username to claim their free upgrade. Once the winners claim their upgrade, we'll announce them here on the site as well.
In the event the issue with Gleam is resolved before the end of the giveaway, we'll just draw two more names from there as well.
We sincerely apologize for this nonsense and want to offer our heartfelt thanks to everyone who participated in the giveaway.
Data Results
Our Christmas theme was declared a big hit with the community, with 88%(!) of the entries grading the theme as a 5 (highest possible rating).
vBulletin and MyBB were the two most requested software, with only "none of the above" coming close. Interestingly enough, all but one entrant that voted for vBulletin voted for MyBB as well. Burning Board had a mere 12 votes and SMF predictably had the lowest total. As a result of this vote, we're going to be discussing the reintroduction of vBulletin and MyBB content and will explore our options for providing official support.
Lastly, the one feature the entrants looked forward to the most is a custom theme for the site, with priority support and a dedicated tutorials area being a close second.
Again, we hope to be able to provide a full recount of all data obtained from this giveaway once everything is cleared up with Gleam.
Thank you all again for being the best damn community!
Merry Christmas!