Both have the + and -, I am sure you would have already gone through it. I am in the same dilemma as my son is asking me for a PS4 pro. I am a xbox fan.
Looking at number of games that are available I think PS4 is handsdown. However, with the new age of cloud games via gamepass I am again not sure which one to go for. At the same time PS5 is schedule for release next year. Should I really invest in any of these consoles now is a big question. So for timebeing happy with xbox at home.